8 Amazing Jewelry Spots to Shop in Indianapolis

If your accessories collection needs an update, check out these great shops and designers for the newest trends and classic pieces.
Jewelry making_Indy Maven

Whether you’re looking for fine jewelry or an affordable pair of earrings to add a pop of color to your favorite outfit, Indy has plenty of great businesses that have exactly what you need. Consider these eight businesses your go-to spots.

Metalmark Fine Jewelry

Metalmark Fine Jewelry is a boutique store with locations in Denver, Colorado and Carmel, Indiana. Check out their spot on Carmel’s Main Street for bold and unique styles that are both classy and fun. 

211 W Main St., Suite 100, Carmel, (720) 441-4635

Kalm Collective

Kalm Collective was founded in 2020 by college friends Kai and London. They offer affordable luxury items like earrings, necklaces, bracelets, and rings. Their pieces are perfect for women who want fun and flexible jewelry that can be used for any occasion.

Petite G Jewelers 

Petite G Jewelers is a local, women-owned jewelry store. Shop with them for classic fine jewelry with a modern twist. They also have a men’s section which is perfect for all your gifting needs.

5609 N. Illinois St., (317) 255-5555

Silver in the City

Silver in the City was founded in 2000 and sells a variety of products from home goods to jewelry. Silver in the City is the perfect place to find pretty and quirky pieces for you or to give as a gift. Plus, they offer a selection of jewelry created by local designers. 

 434 Massachusetts Avenue, (317) 955-9925

 111 W. Main Street, Suite #150, Carmel, (317) 993-3669

Be The Boutique

Be The Boutique carries a variety of items like women’s apparel, home decor, greeting cards, and of course, jewelry. Stop by to check out their bold jewelry that is sure to add a dash of personality to any look. 

5607 North Illinois Street, (317) 257-3826

Sloane Jewelry Design

Sloane Jewelry Design was founded in 2013, and all of their pieces are handmade with high-quality materials. Check out their cute earrings, rings, and necklaces that won’t break your bank.

Nolan James

Nolan James owner, Melissa, makes a point to sell items that are handmade by locally-owned businesses. Their selection is fun and versatile, so you can wear it to your next meeting or date. 

99 Buckeye St., Cicero

Ella Mae’s Boutique

Ella Mae’s Boutique is a local store owned by Abby, a former teacher. Check out their selection of cute studs and bold hoops that are as affordable as they are fashionable. 

19 North Green Street, Brownsburg, (317) 939-0151

Ellie Allen is Indy Maven’s Editorial Intern.

All of our content—including this article—is completely free. However, we’d love if you would please consider supporting our journalism with an Indy Maven membership

Related Posts