Summer in Indy just hits different—and when the temps rise, nothing beats indulging in a sweet, chilly treat. Whether you’re craving a handcrafted scoop of ice cream, a fruity popsicle, or a decadent cupcake, the city is bursting with local gems ready to satisfy your sugar fix. We’ve rounded up the must-visit spots serving up everything from classic cones to over-the-top milkshakes and gourmet goodies, so you can snack your way through the rest of summer in the most delicious way possible.
Brics
With over 60 homemade flavors, BRICS has something for every ice cream lover. Treat yourself to a scoop (or two!)
901 E 64th Street, Indianapolis | www.bricsindy.com
Graeter’s Ice Cream
Get handcrafted ice cream that has been around since 1870 at Graeter’s Ice Cream. Try one of their limited edition flavors: strawberry chocolate chip, orange and cream, peach, or banana chocolate chip.
5560 N. Illinois Street, Indianapolis | www.graeters.com
Lick Indy
Visit Lick Indy for ice cream that starts with the best ingredients and never anything artificial. They make all of their products from scratch in their Indianapolis production space. Visit them at The Garage Food Hall at Bottleworks or in their shop in South Broad Ripple.
906 Carrollton Ave Ste 360 Indianapolis, IN 46202 & 1101 E 52nd Street Indianapolis, IN 46205 | lickindy.com
Nicey Treat
If popsicles are more your thing, stop by Nicey Treat for delicious and refreshing flavor combinations. Try their summer flavors like toasted coconut and key lime pie.
11547 Yard St, Fishers | niceytreat.com
Gordon’s Milkshake Bar
Or if you’re looking for a sweet and tasty milkshake, check out Gordon’s Milkshake Bar for tons of delicious flavors. Try a classic root beer float, decadent chocolate-dipped strawberry shake, or refreshing blueberry cheesecake.
865 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis | Gordon’s Milkshake Bar Instagram
Traders Point Creamery
For great locally made ice cream straight from a dairy farm, head to Traders Point Creamery. Pick up a pint in your favorite flavors or enjoy it on site at Traders Point Creamery’s Dairy Bar.
9101 Moore Road, Zionsville | www.traderspointcreamery.com
Classic Cakes
Mix and match cake, filling, and icing flavors to create an ultimate summer explosion at Classic Cakes. Try cake flavors like lemon, orange, almond, mango, and red velvet cheesecake.
1752 E 116th Street, Carmel | www.classiccakescarmel.com/menu
The Flying Cupcake
The Flying Cupcake has been an Indy staple since 2007 — and rightfully so. Check out their summer flavors like Red Velvet Elvis, Pretty in Pink, and Peanut Butter Blackout.
831 S Rangeline Road, Ste 300, Carmel | www.theflyingcupcakebakery.com
Hart Bakery
Hart Bakery has cakes, bars, cookies, pastries and more. Try their princess bar for summer flavors like raspberry and coconut.
7030 E. 10th Street, Indianapolis | www.hartbakery.com
If those cakes and cupcakes looked good, get to know the women behind them. This story has a round-up of all the local women bakers you should know.
Debrand Chocolates
Debrand Chocolates is known for its high quality, luxury chocolates made from the finest ingredients imported from Belgium, Switzerland, and France. Visit Debrand Chocolates for a tour of the factory and see how their chocolates are made in real time.
8685 River Crossing Blvd. Indianapolis | www.debrand.com
Punkin’s Pies
Head over to Punkin’s Pies located in The Amp at 16 Tech for your favorite sweet treat innovations like cheesecake on a stick, rice crispy treats on a stick, chocolate dipped oreos, cake pops, and more!
1220 Waterway Blvd., Indianapolis | www.punkinspies.com
South Bend Chocolate Company
Find your favorite chocolate confections and ice cream treats at South Bend Chocolate Company in downtown Indianapolis.
30 Monument Circle, Indianapolis | www.sbchocolate.com
Whether you’re team chocolate, fruit, or froyo, there’s no shortage of ways to treat yourself in Indy this season. Grab your besties, hit the streets, and start checking these spots off your summer bucket list—one dreamy dessert at a time, after all, life’s short. Eat the cake. And the ice cream. And maybe a popsicle too.
SUPPORT LOCAL JOURNALISM
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter and join 5,500+ savvy locals getting event recs, insider tips, and exclusive content—like our must-have guide to Indy’s summer hidden gems. Sign up here.
