Skip to main content

Indy Maven’s 2026 Holiday Gift Guide

Shop local this season with gifts from Indy's best small businesses, for everyone on your list (including you!)
a gold wrapped gift on a gold background

The Most Wonderful Time to Shop Local!

The holidays are coming in hot, and if your to-do list looks anything like ours, gift shopping is somewhere between “plan the class party” and “find the matching pajamas.” So we did the legwork for you. Every gift on this list comes from a locally owned Indianapolis or central Indiana business, from Fountain Square to Carmel to Noblesville. There’s something for every budget, from stocking stuffers under $10 to the splurges we’d happily unwrap ourselves. Grab your coffee and let’s get shopping.

For Him

a man holding up a folded Indigofera Baphomet Blanket

Indigofera Baphomet Blanket

For the guy who has everything, including strong opinions about denim. This heirloom-quality blanket is 100% Norwegian wool, woven in a family-owned factory that’s been open since the 1940s, with artwork by Swedish artist Björn Atldax. It’s queen size and reversible, and it’s so striking that a lot of people hang it on the wall as art. Throw it over the couch or let him display it proudly. Either way, it’s built to last.

Indigofera Baphomet Blanket, $399 at dant.us

a bag of Tinker Coffee co. coffee

Tinker Coffee Roaster’s Choice Subscription

For the coffee snob in your life (you know the one). Tinker, one of Indy’s original specialty roasters, ships subscriber-only small-batch roasts on the first Thursday of every month. Pick 2, 3 or 4 bags and choose whole bean, drip or pour-over grind. It’s the gift that keeps showing up long after the tree comes down. Pro tip: sign up by Nov. 28 to get the first box in early December.

Tinker Coffee Roaster’s Choice Subscription, starting at $35 per month at tinkercoffee.com.

Howl + Hide Bifold Wallet

The everyday upgrade he didn’t know he needed. Made in Howl + Hide’s own Fountain Square factory from full-grain leather, this classic bifold has four card pockets and a roomy cash sleeve. It comes with their lifetime guarantee, so it’s the last wallet he’ll ever need.

Bifold Wallet, $99 at howlandhidesupply.com.

For Kids

Sparky Maltose Duck

The stocking stuffer your kids will fight over. This glittery, squishy duck swirls like syrup every time you squeeze it, and it’s weirdly mesmerizing for grown-ups too. Bonus: Goodies & Giggles on Mass Ave does complimentary gift wrapping.

Sparky Maltose Duck, $7.99 at goodiesandgiggles.com.

different colored Sparky Maltose Ducks - a squeezy toy

Dark Side of the Moon Moon Ball

Warning: this will end up on your roof. The Waboba Moon Ball bounces ridiculously high, and this “Dark Side of the Moon” version has metallic dots that make it extra cool. Under $10 and a guaranteed hit in any stocking.

Dark Side of the Moon Moon Ball, $9.99 at goodiesandgiggles.com.

a black moon ball with lime green circles all over it

Indiana Baby

For the littlest Hoosiers. This sweet board book takes babies on a tour of the State Fair, the Children’s Museum, Notre Dame’s Golden Dome and more, with bonus activities in the back so parents can keep the fun going. It’s perfect for a baby’s first Christmas or tucked into a new mom’s gift bag.

Indiana Baby, $9.99 at goodiesandgiggles.com.

I Am Not Grumpy!

For anyone who’s ever been told to smile more. This laugh-out-loud picture book for ages 4 to 8 stars a black rain frog with a serious case of “Resting Frog Face” who swears she’s not grumpy. It’s a Kids’ Indie Next List pick and a sweet lesson in not judging a critter by its cover. Kids Ink, Indy’s beloved children’s bookstore since 1986, offers in-store pickup, or you can have it shipped through their Bookshop.org storefront.

I Am Not Grumpy! by Caroline L. Perry, $19.99 at kidsinkbooks.com or bookshop.org/shop/kidsink.

I am Not Grumpy book cover

For Coworkers

Penn and Beech Jar Candle

Penn & Beech Balsam Fir Candle

Bring the Christmas tree smell, minus the needles. This candle is hand-poured in Indy from a soy wax blend, with notes of fresh pine, bergamot and cedarwood. At $20 for the 8 oz size, it’s the perfect coworker gift, especially with Penn & Beech’s buy 3, get 1 free deal. Stock up for the whole team, and order early since candles are poured to order.

Balsam Fir Candle, starting at $20 at pennandbeech.com.

This Book Is Literally Just Pictures of Cute Dogs That Will Bring You Joy book cover

This Book Is Literally Just Pictures of Cute Dogs That Will Bring You Joy

It does exactly what it says on the cover. This little book of adorable pups is the perfect pick-me-up for the coworker who needs a win this season. Grab it at Silver in the City, voted Indy’s best local gift shop year after year, on Mass Ave or in Carmel.

This Book Is Literally Just Pictures of Cute Dogs That Will Bring You Joy, $16.96 at silverinthecity.com.

For a Friend

Handmade Tiny Heart Necklace

Dainty, sweet and goes with everything. This 3/8″ heart pendant comes in sterling silver or gold vermeil on a 16″ chain with a 2″ extender. Like all of Silver in the City’s jewelry, it arrives boxed and ribboned, so there’s no wrapping required. It’s the kind of everyday piece she’ll never take off.

Handmade Tiny Heart Necklace, $90 at silverinthecity.com.

a silver and gold handmade Handmade Tiny Heart Necklace

Rhone Uptown Herringbone Sweater

For your favorite pickleball partner (or the friend who just looks like she plays). This textured herringbone knit with contrast striping along the sleeves is cozy, preppy and works over a tennis dress or with leggings for errands. Find it at Baseline Social, the Carmel City Center sports boutique owned by three friends who all play at Carmel Racquet Club.

Rhone Uptown Herringbone Sweater, $198 at shopbaselinesocial.com.

a woman wearing a Rhone Uptown Herringbone Sweater

Rototo Coarse Ribbed Old School Crew Socks

The coziest socks you’ll ever gift. These Japanese-made crew socks are thick, fluffy and have a brushed sole that feels bouncy underfoot. The striped, retro style goes with everything from sneakers to slippers. Tip: the small fits men’s shoe sizes 5 to 7, which works for most women.

Rototo Coarse Ribbed Old School Crew Socks, $32 at dant.us.

For Yourself

green Howl + Hide Alice Crossbody Bag

Howl + Hide Alice Crossbody Bag

Small bag, big impact. The Alice is handmade in Howl + Hide’s own Fountain Square factory from full-grain leather and finished with solid brass hardware. Wear it crossbody for errands, or unclip the strap and carry it as a handbag for date night. And if anything ever breaks, they’ll fix it or replace it, for life.

The Alice in Ocean, $309 at howlandhidesupply.com.

Birkenstock Arizona in Croc-Embossed Leather

A Birkenstock, but make it fancy. This croc-embossed take on the classic Arizona feels a little elevated, with shiny metal buckles and the cork footbed that molds to your feet the more you wear it. Pick it up at Stout’s Footwear, which has been fitting Hoosiers since 1886 and is the oldest shoe store in America.

Birkenstock Arizona Leather (Narrow Width) in Black Emboss, $144.95 at stoutsfootwear.com (in-store purchase and pickup only).

a silver bracelet with diamond and sapphire sones from Ankawa Fine Jewelry

A Statement Piece from Ankawa Fine Jewelry

Go ahead, treat yourself. Niv and Hannah Ankawa opened this family-owned boutique on Carmel’s Main Street in December 2025, after nearly 20 years in the fine jewelry business. Instead of the big international brands, they feature select designers and craftsmen, so you’ll find one-of-a-kind pieces you won’t see anywhere else. They also only work with natural diamonds, never lab-grown. This is the splurge you’ll wear for decades.

Ankawa Fine Jewelry, price upon request at ankawafinejewelry.com or 110 W. Main St., Suite 120, Carmel. Estimated starting price of $200–$500 for a smaller fine-jewelry gift.

Experience Gifts

Mahjong Party with Mahj Off Main

Bring the tile craze straight to your living room. Mahj Off Main was founded by Indianapolis local and nonprofit educator Allie, who created an approachable, low-pressure and stylish way to gather friends and learn the game. She brings designer play mats, tile sets and instruction right to your home. Choose Solo Instruction (2 hours, one-on-one, $75), a Group 101 Lesson for up to 12 people (2.5 hours, $50 per person) or a Group 102 Lesson on strategy (2 hours, $35 per person, game card not included).

“When I first tried Mahjong as a new mom, I’ll be honest: I hated it! But coming back to the table with friends helped me realize I didn’t hate the game. I just learned differently. Once it clicked, Mahjong became my favorite way to unplug, laugh and find a little self-care around the table,” Allie says.

Mahj Off Main lessons, starting at $35 per person. Book through @Mahj_Off_Main on Instagram or email mahjoffmain@gmail.com.

Give the Gift of Mahjong

A Facial at Face Foundrié

For the friend who never books anything for herself. Face Foundrié’s focused facial bar at River Crossing offers quick, effective facials, plus lashes and brows, that fit into the busiest schedule. A gift card means she just has to show up.

Face Foundrié gift card at facefoundrie.com. Estimated price: $75–100 for a facial gift card.

Steam and Salt Session at The AromaRoom

It’s like stepping inside a diffuser. Owner Shayla Webb’s Carmel City Center spa offers essential oil steam suites and Himalayan salt rooms, with add-ons like sauna, infrared and red light therapy. The steam suites fit up to six, so book one for your whole crew.

The AromaRoom session or gift card at thearomaroom.us. Starting at $35 for a 30-minute salt therapy session.

a woman in a bathrobe sitting in a shower

Dinner at The Little India Restaurant

Gift a date night that supports two local women. Chef Neeti and co-owner Bhavna bring authentic North Indian cooking to Broad Ripple. Get the butter chicken and save room for the homemade mango ice cream.

The Little India Restaurant thelittleindiarestaurant.com. Best recommended gift card: $50 for a dinner date.

The Little India Restaurant offers gift cards in $10, $25, $50, $75, and $100 denominations, plus custom amounts.

Free Run Wines In Home Wine Tasting

For the wine connoisseur who’s interested in discovering new wines, skip the crowded wine bars and bring the vineyard straight to your living room. Free Run Wines in-home tasting featuring exceptional, curated, storied pours from independent producers. Sip, discover your new favorite bottle, and experience Indiana’s wine distributor focused on stories worth sharing.

Inquire for pricing info@freerun.wine.

Jacque St. Pierre and the First Night at The Cat

A little feline charm and a whole lot of theatrical magic!

Written by Audrey Larkin and illustrated by Fatima Riyan, Jacque St. Pierre and the First Night at The Cat is a delightful children’s book inspired by one of the real-life feline personalities of The Cat, a community theater in Carmel, Indiana.

It’s a sweet, whimsical gift for young readers, cat lovers, and families who appreciate a good story with a local connection.

Where to Buy: The Cat, downtown Carmel, Indiana.

Jacque St. Pierre and the First Night at The Cat - Book Cover

Wrap Up the Season With a Little Local Love!

The best gifts aren’t always the biggest or the fanciest. Sometimes, they’re the ones that bring people together, spark a new hobby, or create memories that last long after the wrapping paper is gone.

And when you shop local, you’re giving something extra special: support to the small businesses, makers, and dreamers who make Indianapolis such a wonderful place to call home.

Here’s to meaningful gifts, happy hearts, and a holiday season filled with a little extra magic.

Happy gifting, Mavens! 🎁

SUPPORT LOCAL JOURNALISM

All of our content—including this article—is entirely free. However, we’d love it if you would please consider supporting our journalism with an Indy Maven Membership.

P.S. Sign up for our weekly newsletter with stories like this delivered to your inbox every Thursday! 

Related Posts