Indy Maven’s 2024 Valentine’s Day Gift Guide

Stuck on what to get your loved ones for Valentine's Day? From bracelets to bouquets, our 2024 Gift Guide has you covered.

Valentine's Day Gift Guide

There are many types of loves to celebrate in life; if we’re lucky—friends, partners, parents, kids, co-workers, the list could go on. Even though it’s important to celebrate those loves every day, Valentine’s Day is a fun excuse to go the extra mile and be a little extra with the “I love you’s.” Whether it’s a simple note, a hand-picked bouquet of flowers from the backyard, or a special dinner out, the same message of love and appreciation is made.

Without further ado, here’s a comprehensive list of Valentine’s Day gift ideas for the different loves in your life.

The Accessory Aficionado

It’s said that gifting someone an open heart symbolizes opening one’s heart to that person. This ring comes in silver and is available in sizes 5-9. Each ring comes boxed and ribboned—easy peasy.

Open Heart Ring, $18 at

This bangle features black diamond stones around a stainless steel gold bangle. Plus, you don’t have to make any decisions—it’s one-size-fits-all and only available in gold.

Gem Heart Hinge Bangle, $20.50 at

These lightweight earrings from Lily and Sparrow Boutique are vintage-inspired and hammered. Each pair is 18k gold-plated stainless steel, tarnish-free, and hypoallergenic.

My Heart Dropped Earrings, $36 at

For that special someone who wears their heart on their….shirt. This pink glitter heart sweatshirt is available in sizes small through 2x and retails for $39.99. In addition to ordering online, in-store pickup is also available.

Pink Glitter Heart Sweatshirt, $39.99 at

Be the Boutique always has the perfect gift. This fun and pink heart pair of socks is perfect for all ages, with sizes in adult medium and large, and child small and medium.

Heart socks, $12 at

The Foodie

This Valentine’s Day special includes your choice of lasagna, either cheese and sauce, meat and cheese, vegetable, gorgonzola, or Johnno’s (aka meat lovers). For another $12, you can throw in a heart-shaped cake in either vanilla, chocolate, or red velvet from Circle City Sweets. Lasagnas and cakes will be delivered to you or your loved one on Feb. 13 or Feb. 14.

Send-A-Friend Valentine’s Day Special, $44.50 – $76 at

Each Valentine’s Day board from 317 Charcuterie comes on a 12’’ heart board (which is yours to keep and reuse again!) with an assortment of meats, cheeses, and sweets, including brie, blueberry goat cheese, gouda, chocolate truffles, and candy hearts. Boards are limited and available while supplies last.

317 Charcuterie, $58 at

Treat yourself and your loved ones this Valentine’s Day to chocolate-covered long-stemmed strawberries from The Best Chocolate in Town – available for a limited time only! Indulge in the perfect blend of juicy strawberries and smooth, velvety chocolate.

The strawberries are only available at the Fashion Mall location on Feb. 10, 13, and 14. They’re also available at the Mass Ave. location on Feb. 14 while supplies last. Grab them before they are gone because love is best served coated in chocolate!

Long-stemmed chocolate-covered strawberries, starting at $30, available in-store only at The Best Chocolate in Town locations. Call (317) 721-5525 or email to pre-order for pick up at one of the locations, including their downtown headquarters on Illinois Street.

Learn the basics of sushi making in this 2-hour and 30-minute class at Katsumis Teaching Kitchen so you can replicate it in your own home. In addition to learning how to make California Rolls, the instructor will also help you learn how to properly use chopsticks.

Intro to Sushi Making class, $110 at

For your friend with a sweet tooth, look no further than cheesecake in a cup from The Cheesecake Lady. Flavor options include strawberry crunch, banana pudding, cookies n’ cream, original, double chocolate brownie, and more. Cups range in size from 4 oz to 12 oz.

Cheesecake Cups, starting at $5.50 at

The Never-Fail Classics

For $25, you and your best gals can make your own unique friendship bracelets together at HopeAnchor & Crew in Noblesville. If you need an additional reason to shop, part of the proceeds go back to charity.

HopeAnchor & Crew Bracelet, $25 at

Pour (your heart out!) with Penn and Beech this Valentine’s Day with its custom candle-making experience. Pouring custom candles together is the perfect way to show that special someone (or your bestie!) how much you care. Advanced reservations are highly suggested, and gift cards are also available in-store or online.

Penn and Beech Custom Blend, starting at $24 at

This Valentine’s Day, give the gift of green love with a 3, 6, or 12-month plant subscription at The Botanical Bar. Each month, a vibrant, easy-to-care plant arrives at your doorstep or is available for pick up in a 4″ grow pot. Enjoy surprises like plant-related activities and free workshops, fostering your green thumb confidence.

Monthly Plant Subscription, $29.99 at

Celebrate love in full bloom with an exquisite limited edition Valentine’s Day bouquet, Blooms of Love,” meticulously hand-designed to captivate your special someone. Bursting with the freshest and most vibrant stems, each arrangement is carefully crafted to convey your deepest emotions. Delivered in iconic Botanical Bar packaging, this bouquet is a testament to quality and style.

Blooms of Love: Valentine’s Day Flower Bouquet, $40-65 at

This bundle is different from the typical dozen red roses and lets customers choose from free spirit roses, blush pink mondial roses, and mixed-color ranunculus bouquets. All bouquets will come with complementary greenery and/or small flowers to complement the bouquet and can be delivered with a vase or wrapped in a brown kraft paper sleeve.

Valentine’s Day Bouquets, starting at $39.90 at

Samantha Kupiainen is a regular Indy Maven contributor.

All of our content—including this article—is completely free. However, we’d love if you would please consider supporting our journalism with an Indy Maven Digital membership.

Related Posts